data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/47d21/47d21e61837016b346063389e62e4bfca428d6f0" alt=""
I probably just wasn't paying attention, but I didn't know this was the design they came up with for the Sept. 11 Memorial. I don't claim to know much about architecture, but I do have some form of taste. I see things that I like, and I see things that look awful. Most of it falls somewhere in between, although I constantly find myself annoyed by all of the boxy strip malls of Bed Bath & Beyonds and Office Depots.
But this goes beyond the cheap architecture of suburbia. This is New York. Our biggest, most recognized city. It is a major symbol of America. Yet this building is wrong on so many levels. Keep in mind, I'm writing this as a sort of knee jerk reaction to seeing the above photo. I don't like how it completely dominates the skyline. It leaves me wondering, should we build a massive (and in my opinion ugly) building that turns the NYC skyline into exclusively a 9/11 memorial?
Should New York forever scream "9/11" to every resident and visitor? It seems unhealthy to me.
As I've said, I don't claim to possess any particular architectural knowledge, but I suspect that many of you will find the building ugly as well. For me, its just one of those instant visual gag reflexes. Perhaps you can articulate it for me, I'm at a loss. And I just don't understand why it can't be somewhat subtle. Must it scream, "Ha! Blow us up again fuckers!?!" I know many people would prefer that we did say that. These people are idiots. Little is accomplished by intentionally egging on the enemy. Instead, perhaps we could focus more on a tasteful memorial created to serve the families of those who lost their loved ones on that tragic day.